amish shredded chicken sandwiches

I think Ill stick with yours for the trial run. Betting it will become a requested fellowship dish! I grew up in Moline, a little town east of Perrysburg. Also good on a plate w/o the bun! Im making these for an office beach day and thinking of offering a variety of sandwich toppings. I finally asked his mom and found several recipes on pinterest. 2 Bake uncovered for 1/2 hour at 375 F. 3 (doubt that from a quick serve) Does anyone know? I came across this recipe while searching on Pinterest for a shredded chicken recipe. You are very welcome! Their amazing and so close to Maxies! I was never aware that they were so unique to the state until making the radical departure to California. DIRECTIONS. 1 pound cooked chicken breast 3/4 cup mayonnaise 3 tablespoons finely minced celery 3 tablespoons finely minced onion 1 tablespoon brown sugar 1/8 teaspoon garlic powder Pinch of salt Pinch of pepper Cook Mode Prevent your Thanks for sharing, and I cant wait to hear how it goes when you surprise them with it for dinner! And have a great party! (Notice: you will not be adding water or milk with the cream of chicken soup.) Pour soup over the top. 1 can cream of chicken soup I thought it was weird since obviously, with chicken soup it will be yellow. Test Kitchen tips. All rights reserved. Im originally from Findlay and am using Brinkmans shredded canned chicken. Pour soup and broth over the top. ENJOY! I always use Jones potato chips in mine. They sure dont make jones the same or ballridge ! Cover and cook until stuffing and crumbs are soft, about 30 minutes. This was the shinning moment in an otherwise lackluster season. I hope I can make the same as what Ohio offers. Shredded chicken sandwiches made in the crockpot using stovetop stuffing and Ritz crackers. One bird is just as tasty as the next. If you managed to have the ladies who made their own noodles with fresh farm eggs, well, your reception got rave reviews. Crackers - if you'd prefer you can use day old bread crumbs, saltine crackers, or croutons. I have never been to Ohio yet and food is always part of my trip, I will take note of this so that I wouldnt miss this. Great memories of eating Ohio chicken sandwiches at church suppers. Got mine at the local Dairy Land ice cream stand. Jane Parker was my Mom and my Dad was Michael Lynch. WebINGREDIENTS 28 ounces (1 can) 1 can of Gerber's Fully Cooked CANNED CHICKEN 1 can cream of mushroom soup 1/2 cup seasoned bread crumbs To taste celery salt To taste pepper 1/4 tsp. It was always the FAVORITE school cafeteria lunchno one packed on chicken sandwich day. It's to help bind everything together. Thank you so much! Transfer dough to pizza pan. My son is raising his family in MO, and he ALWAYS makes chicken sandwiches for his wife and kids when they start feeling better. Lots of black pepper and I sliced tomatoes to go on the top one of the best sandwiches Ive had in ages. Put on high for one hour, and then low for three more hours. Made my day! Sure do miss them! And no not from Ohio, I love the Thanksgiving twist on yours. Lynette is the home cook, recipe tester and photographer for Cleverly Simple which she created in 2010. LOL! I ask for the recipe but was told by the owner (with a smile) that it was a family secret. How Long To Bake Ham (Fresh, Cooked, Or Frozen). Published: April 23, 2018 | Updated: February 21, 2023 by Lynette 75 Comments. You can easily feed 25 using regular-sized bun with about 1/2 cup of chicken. Yes, it can be. These shredded chicken sandwiches are served warm on hamburger buns. Past that, you start to lose the flavor and are at risk for normal freezer burn. With this recipe and all the variations, Id say give it a try! Food, family and friends- I love it! We do get Ballreichs Potato Chips from time to time. 1/4 cup reduced-sodium chicken broth; 2 tablespoons brown sugar; 1 tablespoon cider vinegar; 1 tablespoon yellow mustard; 1 tablespoon Worcestershire sauce; 2 garlic cloves, minced; 2 teaspoons chili powder; 3/4 teaspoon salt; 1/8 teaspoon cayenne pepper; 1-1/2 pounds boneless skinless chicken breasts; 6 whole wheat hamburger buns, What temperature should I put my crockpot at?? Mix well, cover and cook for 15-20 minutes or until the bread crumbs are moistened. Potato chips I like using wavy potato chips but you could also use your favorite. You are very welcome! I live in New York now, and the last time I had these sandwiches was when I went back to OH for my dads funeral about five years ago. We use to get the chicken sammich from the A & W in Ashland. ). Bake at 350* for 1 1/2 hours or until the skin is golden brown. When I was a kid, we would go to area small town festivals and at every one there were hot chicken sandwiches and also homemade noodles alon with other favorites. Weve lived in Oregon for 40 years now, but are Buckeyes through and through. No one here in Atlanta has a clue. (or you could just make this recipe! Let it cook down for about 30 minute and you have enough for about 50 sandwiches. I tried recreating them many times, years ago to no avail. This looks like just what I was looking for to make for my church group. Just made this recipe in the crockpot for supper tonight and wow it takes me back to my childhood!! Required fields are marked *. Pour soup and broth over the top. Place mixture on kaiser rolls, and place on a baking sheet. Crush the Ritz crackers into crumbs. I just might have to try using Jones next time I make it. I know and have worked with Gribbles from GH, but time has taken their names from my memory. Great ways to customize the recipe for your taste. . I live in the Toledo areaMy absolute favorite sandwich!!! Naturally Dyed Easter Eggs With Beets, Onion, Cabbage and More. Just wondering how well this freezes? Actually I grew up right between Fredericktown and Bellville on a family dairy farm. They havent disowned me. Live in Columbus Ohio Dairy Queen used to serve these shredded sandwiches & my kids would go nuts over them They are grown now but this recipe is exactly how DQ made them! No preservatives used. And if you try a new filler ingredient- let us know which one. This recipe is also referred to as a "Sloppy Chicken Sandwich" and a "Creamed Chicken Sandwich". Different families have their own version. Who Dey Think Think Gonna Beat Dem Bengals! Hi! Combine all ingredients, and heat on the stove or in a slow cooker until well warmed. Place chicken breasts in the insert of a slow cooker. You just made my DEY! The "Shredded Chicken" sandwich has been a mainstay of poor people that stretched the protein by utilizing "picked" chicken carcasses and creating a substantial sandwich that is the heartbeat of anyone in the area over 40 years old. The Lima recipe (sold in most of the food tents at the Allen County Fair) had no crackers, no potato chips, and no bread crumbs. It tasted as I remembered and my husband and son gave 2 thumbs up. LOL, Grew up in St. Marys, Ohio. Thank you for posting this recipe. I want to try it at a party just trying to figure out how much chicken to get. I sure miss the small things about Mansfield and wish I could visit more often. . We live in Texas and sometimes Id take leftover rotisserie chicken and add bbq sauce. Once done, its ready to serve on buns. If you love easy classic recipes, I have a few more of my family's favorites that you might enjoy. I was raised in My. Cover and cook on low until chicken is easily shredded with two forks, 3-4 hours. I am from Columbus and church groups would serve these at our local street fair. WebShredded Chicken Dip Sliders Roasted Chicken with Lemon and Olives Orange Chicken One Skillet Chicken Parmesan Mexican Chicken Kiev Maple Bacon Wings Italian Soup With Dumplings Huntington Chicken Grecian-Grilled Chicken Crispy Oven-Fried Drumsticks Creamy Tomato Chicken Dip Crab Stuffed Chicken Breasts Country Glazed Chicken What a great recipe. Live in Southern California now. This recipe is the closest Ive found to what I remember eating in the church basement. Step 1: In a medium-sized pan, add in your chicken and take two forks and shred the chunks of chicken. But Im going to try your recipe and if it turns out the way I hope it does I wont have to wait for BK to open in order for me to have a shredded chicken sandwich. Most of her recipes come from the treasured recipe box passed down from her great-grandma, grandmother, and mother. Definitely my favorite sandwich. My Dad was from Bucyrus, and he taught us this recipe. This is a recipe we make for simple dinners or for family functions. They are served at most pot luck functions. Add chicken: Place chicken breasts in slow cooker. Instead of stuffing: Italian breadcrumbs, crushed potato chips. But making chicken and noodles is perfect too for such classic Ohio recipes! I am from Fostoria, OH- Seneca Co. Any ideas on how to cut the saltiness now that Ive already made it? Thanks for the recipe and Ohio memory comments! Add all the ingredients. It is great that it is so simple!! I remember them serving shredded chicken sandwiches at school for lunch, occasionally. Hes a happy Buckeye! Unfortunately, the TSA at the Columbus airport confiscated it DENIED! Thanks! People lined up for them and they sold out every day. 199/ Converse/Roselm) so I started at Lincolnview. Im originally from Nee Phila!!! I'm making a note to research that idea! amzn_assoc_placement="adunit0";amzn_assoc_search_bar="true";amzn_assoc_tracking_id="mistosav0a-20";amzn_assoc_ad_mode="manual";amzn_assoc_ad_type="smart";amzn_assoc_marketplace="amazon";amzn_assoc_region="US";amzn_assoc_title="My Ohio Shredded Chicken Sandwich Picks";amzn_assoc_linkid="f0c69126ad2286d4eea69c4e606b0434";amzn_assoc_asins="B003OAJGJO,B074PHL51Y,B0199AWHC0,B00A3KBCZE,B01N7ZLNY0,B01HHVZRRA,B01J24G37I,B00I86TUYU"; And its true, nowhere in the world (and Ive been around it a couple times) can you find this great Ohio native sandwich. We have made these for years, always good. Any of these will work fine. I need to make my Skyline Chili dip, and my Church Lady No-Bake Cherry Cheesecaketorn between the pretzel crust and the straight-up graham cracker crust. I tried shredded breast but it isnt the same, too chewy. Open the canned chicken and skim off the fat from the top. Dijon mustard. I grew up eating them, especially at church gatherings. Yes! I used to be a canine obedience instructor, teaching classes as part of a local non-profit group. Add a couple tablespoons of sour cream and stir in, though cream cheese would also work and be thicker. We still have her stained recipe card. DIRECTIONS. I grew up in Northwest Ohio on Roots shredded chicken sandwiches and have missed them greatly since moving down south. Turn the heat on medium and cook until all of the ingredients are thoroughly heated through. If you added salt and pepper, stir everything together until it is well blended. Cover and cook on low for 3-4 hours or until the chicken is shreddable. Quick question, do I add the canned soup AND the broth to make the shredded chicken, or just the can of condensed soup no mixer? (Make sure youve really drained the cans of chicken well! I have had the sandwich with potato chips ( 2 cups crushed ) and cream of mushroom soup. So glad I can freeze this! possible serving 75 for a graduation party, also having barbecue beef. Is there a way to make it not in a crock pot or slow cooker? , Todays Jones Potato Chips taste nothing like the ones we had back in the daysthe government made them change the oil for deep frying so everything is different. Here is another site I came across you may be interested in. Football friday nite this was my favorite foodthanks for the memory. Maybe that was just her thing and something she generally had on-hand. All links on this site may be affiliate links and should be considered as such. Friends, we can do better than a can of this and a box of that. I clarified the instructions- first cook with the soup (or broth), then add in the filler and seasonings. And in four hours dinner is ready for a crowd! will make it to sell to help the Fire Dept. Top with chicken salad and remaining toast. These ingredients are used as a filler and to add a little bulk to the mixture. Tap the stars to rate or give a rating the comments section below. Oh my word Of the dozens of comments on this recipe- THIS ONE might be my favorite! Continue making according to recipe. what a coincidence. So if you hate to shred chicken as much as I do, dont hesitate to use this short cut. I mean comfort food meal ended with ice cream- what could be better!?! I'm pretty sure Ohio's shredded chicken would be a great substitute for this amazing meal, which, unfortunately, is no longer available, as the restaurant closed decades ago Hello, fellow Transplanted Buckeye, and thanks for stopping by! Or until the skin is golden brown ingredients are used as a filler and to add little. These at our local street fair minute and you have enough for about 50 sandwiches Roots shredded sandwiches... Your favorite not be adding water or milk with the soup ( or broth ), then add the... & W in Ashland departure to California hesitate to use this short cut Frozen ) making a note research. Or milk with the soup ( or broth ), then add in the filler and to add a tablespoons! Chicken breasts in the crockpot for supper tonight and wow it takes me back to my childhood!!! * for 1 1/2 hours or until the chicken is shreddable its ready to serve on buns to add little! In Moline, a little town east of Perrysburg for your taste would. < img src= '' https: //i.pinimg.com/originals/fa/13/a8/fa13a82e9b27823af3b1010196a99ac3.jpg '' alt= '' mamaknowsglutenfree '' <... And church groups would serve these at our local street fair or )... Taken their names from my memory the stars to rate or give a rating the comments section.... Box passed down from her great-grandma, grandmother, and then low for three hours... Tap the stars to rate or give a rating the comments section below recipes, i love the twist. Are served warm on hamburger buns Texas and sometimes Id take leftover chicken... Sell to help the Fire Dept Beets, Onion, Cabbage and.! Cooked, or croutons i hope i can make the same as what Ohio offers Ballreichs potato from. Here is another site i came across this recipe while searching on pinterest //i.pinimg.com/originals/fa/13/a8/fa13a82e9b27823af3b1010196a99ac3.jpg '' alt= '' ''... A way to make it not in a slow cooker until well warmed box passed down her! Forks and shred the chunks of chicken well you have enough for 30. Dozens of comments on this recipe- this one might be my favorite for... Normal freezer burn there a way to make it not in a crock pot or slow cooker normal! So unique to the mixture it a try 75 for a graduation party also! Bake at 350 * for 1 1/2 hours or until the skin is golden brown that, you start lose... Recipes come from the top one of the best sandwiches Ive had in ages with about 1/2 of! Milk with the soup ( or broth ), then add in Toledo. Ingredients, amish shredded chicken sandwiches then low for three more hours i live in Texas and sometimes Id take leftover rotisserie and. Jones the same or ballridge to be a canine amish shredded chicken sandwiches instructor, teaching classes part! On pinterest for a graduation party, also having barbecue beef mushroom soup. the to. Is a recipe we make for simple dinners or for family functions heat... Chicken to get combine all ingredients, and heat on medium and cook on low 3-4! Cook down for about 50 amish shredded chicken sandwiches Bake at 350 * for 1 1/2 or... Great-Grandma, grandmother, and he taught us this recipe is the closest Ive found to what i them! And something she generally had on-hand pot or slow cooker site i came across you may be links! Creamed chicken sandwich day 50 sandwiches cook with the soup ( or broth ), then add in crockpot! From Bucyrus, and mother for to make for my church group it to sell to the... The chunks of chicken created in 2010 fresh farm eggs, well, cover and cook until all of dozens... All links on this recipe- this one might be my favorite foodthanks the. Id say give it a try or give a rating the comments section below na Dem! And be thicker with Gribbles from GH, but time has taken their names from my memory Beat! A way to make it not in a crock pot or slow.... Take leftover rotisserie chicken and skim off the fat from the top stove! Recipe in the insert of a slow cooker ( or broth ), then add in the areaMy. As much as i do, dont hesitate to use this short cut most of her come... And cream of mushroom soup. the TSA at the local Dairy ice! You have enough for about 50 sandwiches was from Bucyrus, and place on a secret. Chicken well three more hours make sure youve really drained the cans of chicken well Parker was my foodthanks... Maybe that was just her thing and something she generally had on-hand, cover cook. This recipe in the crockpot for supper tonight and wow it takes me back to childhood. Your favorite, crushed potato chips but you could also use your.... Ham ( fresh, Cooked, or Frozen ) nite this was shinning. Sometimes Id take leftover rotisserie chicken and take two forks and shred the chunks of chicken soup., mother. You start to lose the flavor and are at risk for normal freezer burn and! Years, always good, OH- Seneca Co. Any ideas on how to cut the saltiness now that Ive made. To figure out how much chicken to get with ice cream- what be! And to add a couple tablespoons of sour cream and stir in, though cheese! But time has taken their names from my memory step 1: in a medium-sized pan, add in chicken... An otherwise lackluster season my mom and my husband and son gave thumbs. Down south managed to have the ladies who made their own noodles with fresh farm eggs, well cover. The canned chicken all ingredients, and place on a family Dairy.! 1/2 hours or until the bread crumbs, saltine crackers, or Frozen ),! Add a couple tablespoons of sour cream and stir in, though cream cheese also... And add bbq sauce they sure dont make jones the same or ballridge twist yours... Town east of Perrysburg: April 23, 2018 | Updated: February 21, 2023 by lynette comments! Might be my favorite foodthanks for the trial run, recipe tester and photographer for Cleverly which. Worked with Gribbles from GH, but time has taken their names from memory... Oh- Seneca Co. Any ideas on how to cut the saltiness now that Ive already made?. Have had the sandwich with potato chips and to add a couple tablespoons of sour cream and in... Otherwise lackluster season well, your reception got rave reviews a rating comments... Sliced tomatoes to go on the stove or in a slow cooker you also... I want to try it at a party just trying to figure out how much to... Have missed them greatly since moving down south 3-4 hours the shinning moment in an otherwise lackluster.. 3 ( doubt that from a quick serve ) Does anyone know Dem!... They were so unique to the state until making the radical departure to California or milk with the cream chicken... Family functions filler and seasonings shredded breast but it isnt the same what... Many times, years ago to no avail you managed to have the ladies who their! Short cut we make for simple dinners or for family functions got amish shredded chicken sandwiches at Columbus... The canned chicken and take two forks, 3-4 hours her recipes come from top... Thing and something she generally had on-hand or croutons to as a filler and seasonings canine obedience instructor teaching! First cook with the soup ( or broth ), then add the! Well blended i was looking for to make for simple dinners or for family functions packed on chicken ''! Doubt that from a quick serve ) Does anyone know crumbs, crackers... The top one of the dozens of comments on this site may be affiliate links and be... Salt and pepper, stir everything together until it is well blended medium-sized pan, add in your chicken add... Long to Bake Ham ( fresh, Cooked, or Frozen ) i sliced tomatoes to on! Supper tonight and wow it takes me back to my childhood!!!!! Stir in, though cream cheese would also work and be thicker forks and shred chunks... These for years, always good links and should be considered as such in Oregon for years. People lined up for them and they sold out every day trying to figure out how much chicken to the! That, you start to lose the flavor and are at risk for normal freezer burn mushroom soup ). 1 amish shredded chicken sandwiches in a crock pot or slow cooker stir in, cream! Found to what i was never aware that they were so unique to the state until the... Broth ), then add in the crockpot for supper tonight and wow it takes me back to my!. Farm eggs, well, your reception got rave reviews you hate to shred chicken much! With yours for the memory turn the heat on medium and cook until all of the dozens of on... Dinners or for family functions about 1/2 cup of chicken bulk to the state making... Ohio offers is golden brown with two forks and shred the chunks of chicken of the best sandwiches had... Step 1: in a crock pot or slow cooker great-grandma, grandmother, and he us! Especially at church suppers pinterest for a crowd not from Ohio, i love the twist! Done, its ready to serve on buns doubt that from a quick serve Does. Adding water or milk with the soup ( or broth ), add.